I contributed a comment to the excellent blog, Psephizo, earlier today summarising how I felt in response to Bishop Michael Curry's sermon at the royal wedding this weekend. It's received a lot of press and many people are talking about it (the sermon, not my comment, hah!), but I can't seem to get excited in quite the same way as many of my peers....
...
First though, as I'm likely to be critical, I should say that I did enjoy the sermon. It was passionate, memorable, and probably came as wonderful shock to the ears of many who think church, and preaching in particular, to be a lifeless, soulless or guilt-inducing experience.
However I didn't think it particularly distinctive as a christian message and was pleased to find I wasn't alone in thinking it.
The best commentary came from Gavin Ashenden. If anything, he’s rather more
critical than I think was nessecary, to the point of being rather cynical; especially compared to other commentators from within the church. However, I felt Ashenden rightly focused on the absence of
‘christological substance’, and that should be the main critique. This is being held up by many as a ‘gospel message’, as if love and gospel are synonyms.
I don't agree with him that this was simply a 'pop' message, calculated deliberately to water-down the church's message, nor do I think this an idea endorsed by Welby (as some are suggesting), but I do think his deconstruction of the message was spot on. After all, what we got was
certainly a powerful and memorable exhortation to love, yet the message remained largely devoid of it’s sacrificial and salvific anchoring
points. The love God shows us and the love we have for each other, while related, are not the same in effect, motive or magnitude...
Second, I really appreciated Mark Stibbe’s comment on Facebook
(echoed by the Rev David Shepherd, another commentator) about the poeticism,
lyricism and value of this distinctively African-American rhetorical
style, and it's origins.
It’s clearly not an area I’m well qualified comment on, given that I’m
pretty naive about it. Being honest, my only encounters with genuine African-American churches or gospel music is from the preaching of S.M.Lockridge, or obvious Hollywood stereotypes (Sister Act and the Blues Brothers spring to mind), but I think in any discussion about what preachers
can learn from Michael Curry (and there is lots we can!) we should pay more dues to the origins of
his style, and it is definitely something I'd look to learn more about.
Third though, and most importantly perhaps, is simply a reflection on
conversations I’ve had since, almost all of which have been positive.
Many of my non-Christian friends and acquaintances have expressed
surprise and delight in hearing such ‘life’ in a sermon (as my neighbor
put it), and I enjoyed having the opportunity to say in response that
there is life in Jesus Christ and His church, and maybe they should come
and find out more.
So yes, I may have my personal critique, but I cannot deny the
overwhelmingly positive response. Such a public event, with such a
memorable (if flawed) sermon, should be put to good use in our
evangelism and witness.
I contributed a comment to the excellent blog, Psephizo, earlier today summarising how I felt in response to Bishop Michael Curry's sermon at the royal wedding this weekend. It's received a lot of press and many people are talking about it (the sermon, not my comment, hah!), but I can't seem to get excited in quite the same way as many of my peers....
...
First though, as I'm likely to be critical, I should say that I did enjoy the sermon. It was passionate, memorable, and probably came as wonderful shock to the ears of many who think church, and preaching in particular, to be a lifeless, soulless or guilt-inducing experience.
However I didn't think it particularly distinctive as a christian message and was pleased to find I wasn't alone in thinking it.
The best commentary came from Gavin Ashenden. If anything, he’s rather more critical than I think was nessecary, to the point of being rather cynical; especially compared to other commentators from within the church. However, I felt Ashenden rightly focused on the absence of ‘christological substance’, and that should be the main critique. This is being held up by many as a ‘gospel message’, as if love and gospel are synonyms.
I don't agree with him that this was simply a 'pop' message, calculated deliberately to water-down the church's message, nor do I think this an idea endorsed by Welby (as some are suggesting), but I do think his deconstruction of the message was spot on. After all, what we got was certainly a powerful and memorable exhortation to love, yet the message remained largely devoid of it’s sacrificial and salvific anchoring points. The love God shows us and the love we have for each other, while related, are not the same in effect, motive or magnitude...
Here's the link: https://ashenden.org/2018/05/19/michael-curry-the-royal-wedding-a-star-turn-offers-the-world-christianity-lite/
Second, I really appreciated Mark Stibbe’s comment on Facebook (echoed by the Rev David Shepherd, another commentator) about the poeticism, lyricism and value of this distinctively African-American rhetorical style, and it's origins.
It’s clearly not an area I’m well qualified comment on, given that I’m pretty naive about it. Being honest, my only encounters with genuine African-American churches or gospel music is from the preaching of S.M.Lockridge, or obvious Hollywood stereotypes (Sister Act and the Blues Brothers spring to mind), but I think in any discussion about what preachers can learn from Michael Curry (and there is lots we can!) we should pay more dues to the origins of his style, and it is definitely something I'd look to learn more about.
Third though, and most importantly perhaps, is simply a reflection on conversations I’ve had since, almost all of which have been positive. Many of my non-Christian friends and acquaintances have expressed surprise and delight in hearing such ‘life’ in a sermon (as my neighbor put it), and I enjoyed having the opportunity to say in response that there is life in Jesus Christ and His church, and maybe they should come and find out more.
So yes, I may have my personal critique, but I cannot deny the overwhelmingly positive response. Such a public event, with such a memorable (if flawed) sermon, should be put to good use in our evangelism and witness.
Mat Sheffield,
May 2018