Ken Livingstone has resigned. You can read his letter and some commentary here via the BBC http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-44196298
....
I wont beat around the bush, I didn't like Ken Livingstone much (I actually met him once), but I can't help feeling bad for him in all of this. Claiming that "Hitler supported Zionism", as he is quoted as saying, is not I would argue, 'abhorrent' or 'anti-Semitic' in itself (as his own party seems determined to slander him with), it is a lazy historical generalization.
He should have been asked to clarify what he meant, as he subsequently has done, and perhaps reprimanded, but nothing else.
After all, Ken is partly right. The Nazis did have an early policy (in the 30s) to expedite the Jews abroad to Palestine, which is clearly what Ken was referring too. However, it cannot be said to have been a 'supportive' policy, as:
- First, it was categorically not for their (the Jews') benefit. The jews were forced to leave all their material possessions to the state as they left, and;
- Second, literally everyone thought it was a terrible idea at the time; Nazis and Jews alike!
Hitler certainly wasn't motivated by Zionism (a much-abused and misunderstood concept), but rather by cold, brutal pragmatism. Crucially though, and this is what everyone seems to have missed, Ken wasn't advocating for the Nazis, or passing judgement on the policy's merit; he was (in a case of extreme irony) actually warning against the dangers of making lazy historical generalisations around issues of antisemitism!
He chose his words badly and was wrong; his resignation letter admits as much, but that does not make him a racist and he is right to resist the label. This is scapegoating, and I'm actually a little sad that principled Labour activists and MPs are standing for it.
Mat Sheffield
May 2018

Comments
Post a Comment